2025

Riley Marks - Richmond

Jayne Michaels - Temple

Ally Flynn - Scranton

2024

Sofia Fanelli - Quinnipiac

Cami Yard - Xavier

Karyn Michaels - Marist

Finley Mulhern - Iona

Lexie Conte - Pitt

Kendall Willard - Millersville

Ally Kennedy - Gettysburg

2023

Eileen Hewitt - Scranton

2022

Nickie Predergast - American

Macenzie Heragos - IUP

Jordan Higgins - Shenandoah 

2021

Caroline Brennan - Monmouth

Hazel Gardner - JMU

Jill Kennedy - Catholic

Alli Hunter - Longwood

Sophia Colantuno - Belmont Abby College

2020

Liv Fanelli - Monmouth

Lauren Carey - Old Dominion

Ava Irwin - Neumann

Kya Effinger - Millersville

2019

Livi Lawton - UNC

Jess Myers - West Chester

Caroline Person - Long Island University

Emily Wurzel - Cincinnati

2018

Leah Hunter - IUP

Hannah Wurzel - Wofford

Haleigh Wurzel - Mercer

Caroline Webb - Saint Joe's (Field Hockey)

2017

Victoria Barretta - Maryland

Elise Person - Long Island University

2015

Abby Savidge - United States Naval Academy

2014

Nicole Barretta - Stony Brook

2012

McKenzie Rafferty - Delaware

Haley Swartz - Quinnipiac (Field Hockey)

Kaitlin Brannan - Wesley College

Haley Nelson - West Chester

2011

Kelly Devlin - UNC

Emily Solenberger - Lehigh

Ashley Poli - West Chester

Marya Fratoni - UConn

Allie Murray - Notre Dame

2009

Kelli Joran - Drexel